…and then Kashmir will smell sweet [Part 1]

Let’s Exercise Our Votes For A Peaceful Path To A Better Tomorrow


now improve understanding and trust

By Neeraj Bhushan

There is an audience in Pakistan. There is an audience in India. And then there is a huge audience all over the world. Yes, when it comes to the K world, everyone talks to one’s own audience. Maybe this is the prime reason why Kashmir remains a flashpoint. Must I mention that my English teacher, in a military school, explained to me the meaning of the phrase ‘Apple of Discord’ in the following terms: “Kashmir is an apple of discord between India and Pakistan.”

Gosh! Why was it planted into my young innocent mind then itself, that Kashmir somehow relates to a problem and it is not just a beautiful Indian state! Ever since, as I matured at colleges and then into a complete Indian, Kashmir has always appeared to me a thirsty territory. Why don’t we realise collectively that Kashmir is indeed a ladder must we climb today before it’s rather too late. Let’s not invoke Shakespeare time and again that roses always come with thorns. Let the people of Jammu and Kashmir realise that WE (that includes anything anywhere) indeed want to solve the issue(s) at hand, once and for all.

The two hot parties involved in this – India and Pakistan – must not kill any opportunity that they feel has the potential of providing everlasting peace in the sub-continent. Hasn’t so much effort and hard work already gone into it? We also have had umpteen photo opportunities discussing Indo-Pak relations. But aren’t there some real, hard issues which need to be addressed?

So, let us not have any illusions either. We should not be assuming that we have solved everything (or that we will not solve anything) and everything is fine. We should begin understanding now that the dialogues between the two sides have to give results after all. It has already taken much time for the outstanding issues to be resolved. The difficulty levels of either parties are also well estimated. And as a matter of fact, who does not know the subject through and through!

Leaders and officials of India and Pakistan – the two neighbours – have also met many a times, even in the recent past, and held peace talks on all issues. But, then, any progress between them has halted. Blame it on 2008 Mumbai terror attacks!!!

But how far have we gone on the prescriptions — There are steps that we could take: confidence building measures, addressing the trust deficit, promoting better people-to-people exchanges, making it easier for trade and business exchanges, dealing with the subject of terrorism and the counter-terrorism measures that we need to put in place, narcotics, trade across the Line of Control (LoC), Sir Creek, Siachen, Jammu and Kashmir, peace and security and promotion of friendly exchanges.

It’s not that I haven’t seen competent authorities and leaders being as frank as they can, while speaking on Indo-Pak ties or the K word. But then I have also seen them falling silent, not saying anything anymore. Soon, they appear with bladder of unseen constraints.

Wish the audiences in India, Pakistan and the world over could extract confessions from the respective leaders as to what holds them back. As an Indian, the issue like ‘terrorism’ obviously concerns me. As a world citizen, the issue like ‘tourism’ concerns me. As a human being, the issue like ‘living happily’ concerns me. And I believe all these are equally important for any other living being on the planet earth. Then why don’t you discuss it with the right intentions, to resolve the issues, whatsoever, for bringing peace.

Kuldip Nayar. The Gappuccino photo by Neeraj Bhushan

Kuldip Nayar

Writing for Pakistan’s Dawn newspaper, eminent Indian columnist Kuldip Nayar had noted: “I have no doubt that the Kashmir problem will be solved sooner or later. But too much has happened in the state in the past. This makes it difficult for the old Kashmir to come back to life. Familiar symbols are dying. Sufism has been replaced by assertive teachings. Kashmiri music is dying out because society has been forced to acquire a religious edge. Old crafts attract fewer artisans because there is a race to earn a quick buck.

The wazwan, a string of Kashmiri dishes served at one sitting, is still there but new cooks are hard to get. The reintegration of Muslims and Pandits appears difficult. An Islamic identity has taken shape, reportedly more in the countryside. Kashmiriyat, a secular ethos, is beyond repair. The animosity among the three regions Kashmir, Jammu and Ladakh, may dilute but will remain. It may still remain the state of Jammu and Kashmir. But its soul would be missing.

[To be concluded]


The Gappuccino also featured Shivani Virani’s FIRST HAND post on Kashmir

Click Here To Read

22 Years Later – Kashmir As I Saw It

5 thoughts on “…and then Kashmir will smell sweet [Part 1]

  1. Pingback: Kashmir – A Thirsty Territory « GREATER VOICE™

  2. Pingback: …and then Kashmir will smell sweet [Part 4] | g caffè

  3. I am of an opinion,as I read 80 percent of Chinese don’t recollect 1962 war with India.Then why make so much emphasis on war with China and China being not trusted.Same would apply for Pakistan. Vast average might not recollect the war with East Pakistan.It is in India’s interest not to keep reminding the public about it.Today Indian public has very good relations with all its neighbours. With internet revolution, whole world is connected.Topic might be raised for political importance on terror being sponsored by neighbouring countries. I would request the governments to please check on the blasts in the country which is being blamed to sponsor terrorism. One must not forget the foundation of our neighbours. Many families, one or more than one member had shifted there for a better and secure future. Some had taken more caution in only shifting one half of the family,just in case it was a bad idea shifting. This trend was followed all over the subcontinent. Even today daughters are wed in close relatives only across the border. When a community or a government accuses the other, it is actually accussing immediate families of many across the borders.


  4. Pingback: …and then Kashmir will smell sweet [Part 2] | g caffè

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s